The 2026 Kentucky Charter School Ruling (HB 9) in Brief: What the Court Said and What It Means for Families
By My Learning Source · November 22, 2026 · News, Guides
On February 19, 2026, the Kentucky Supreme Court ruled on the state's charter school law. If you homeschool, you might wonder why you should care. Charter schools are public schools, not a homeschool option. But the ruling says a lot about what Kentucky's Constitution allows, and that shapes every school choice debate that touches families like yours. Here's the short version. The full timeline is in our Kentucky homeschool options guide.
What HB 9 did
HB 9 (2022) rewrote Kentucky's public charter school law and set out how charter schools would be funded with state and local education money. The bill record shows it passed the House 51–46 on March 22, 2022 and the Senate 22–14 on March 29. Governor Andy Beshear vetoed it on April 7, 2022, and the General Assembly overrode the veto on April 13, the House 52–46 and the Senate 22–15. It became 2022 Ky. Acts ch. 213.
Under Kentucky's charter statutes, as the Court described them, a charter school states its maximum enrollment per grade in its application, uses a lottery when more students apply than there are seats, and operates outside the control of the local school district.
How the case got to the Supreme Court
The Council for Better Education asked the Franklin Circuit Court to declare HB 9 unconstitutional, naming the Commissioner of Education and the Kentucky Board of Education. The Attorney General and a charter school applicant from Madison County joined the case to defend the law. The circuit court barred the state from carrying out HB 9's provisions and from spending tax dollars on charter schools under it. The appeals were transferred to the Supreme Court.
What the Court decided
In Commonwealth ex rel. Coleman v. Council for Better Education (2024-SC-0022-TG), the Court affirmed the circuit court and held that HB 9 violates Sections 183, 184 and 186 of the Kentucky Constitution (Supreme Court minutes, February 19, 2026). The opinion notes that all justices sat on the case and all concurred, with a separate concurring opinion as well.
The reasoning, in plain English:
- Section 183 requires the General Assembly to provide "an efficient system of common schools." Section 184 says money raised for common school education goes to the common schools "and to no other purpose." Section 186 says school fund money is for the public schools "and for no other purpose."
- A common school, the Court said, has to be open to every eligible child in its district, run under local school authorities and funded by taxes. Charter schools under HB 9 could cap enrollment, use lotteries and weren't answerable to local districts, so they weren't common schools.
- Paying for them with public education money therefore sent that money outside the common school system, which the Constitution doesn't allow.
The Court put it this way: the Constitution "as it stands is clear that it does not permit funneling public education funds outside the common public school system." It also said, "Innovation is welcome; circumvention is not." And it said it made no predictions about how charter schools would perform and left public policy judgments to the General Assembly.
Chief Justice Lambert also wrote a separate concurring opinion, joined by Justice Thompson. It agreed with the result and added concerns that the law handed the General Assembly's constitutional duty to oversee the public schools to charter authorizers. It also said that any change to these limits must come in the form of a constitutional amendment.
How it connects to 2022 and 2024
The opinion leans on two earlier events. It summed up the 2022 ruling against the Education Opportunity Account program, noted at KRS 141.500, as a plan to "subsidize non-common school education without the voter-approved tax that Section 184 requires." And it pointed to the November 2024 defeat of Amendment 2, which would have let the General Assembly fund education outside the common schools (certified results). Read together, the three events make one point: in Kentucky, state money for education outside the public schools runs into the Constitution.
What it means for families
- If you homeschool: nothing in your legal routine changes. Your notice under KRS 159.030, your attendance and scholarship records, and your choice of curriculum are untouched.
- If you were watching a charter school proposal near you: the funding under HB 9 was held unconstitutional. For the status of a specific school, ask the Kentucky Department of Education or your district; we didn't find an official statewide list to point you to.
- If you're hoping for state help with homeschool costs: this ruling reinforces the limits the account program hit in 2022. The 2027 federal scholarship tax credit, which Kentucky joined through HB 1 (2026), runs through federal law and private scholarship granting organizations, and whether it reaches homeschool costs isn't settled.
- If you want a school-like setting without leaving homeschooling: co-ops, hybrid programs and private classes remain open to you, paid privately.
One family's decision
The Bakers, outside Richmond, had followed the charter school news since their oldest was in third grade. They liked the idea of a small school with a science focus, and they'd talked about trying one if it ever opened nearby. After the February ruling, they sat down and asked what they actually wanted: smaller classes, hands-on science and a schedule that fits Dad's shift work. They found most of that in a two-day-a-week homeschool co-op in Madison County and a monthly lab class from a local science tutor. They still homeschool under their yearly notice, and they spend about what they spent before.
(A composite example — names and details are illustrative, drawn from situations homeschool families commonly describe.)
Your checklist
- Understand the ruling: HB 9 was held unconstitutional on February 19, 2026, under Sections 183, 184 and 186.
- Know it doesn't change homeschool law.
- For a specific charter proposal, ask KDE or your district for its status.
- Look for co-ops and hybrid programs through our community, and classes and tutors in our vendor directory.
- Check our education calendar for open houses, fairs and workshops near you.
My Learning Source is an independent marketplace and is not affiliated with the Kentucky Supreme Court, the Kentucky Department of Education, the Kentucky Board of Education, the Kentucky General Assembly or any charter school or applicant. Court rulings and laws change — confirm details with the official source before you act. Family examples are composites, not real individuals.